Difference between Teaching and Indoctrination
Key Difference: Teaching is all about communication of information, ideas or skills that can be questioned or discussed and the facts that are taught in teaching are supported by evidence, whereas indoctrination is about communication of beliefs that are not supported by any evidence and the receiver is supposed to accept it the way it has been taught without any arguement or questioning.
Teaching is a simple word and we often use it in our every day life but indoctrination seems to be a little difficult word. It is difficult in the sense that it arises the curiosity but still defining it is little complicated. Teaching is used by many people but the word indoctrination is rarely used, but somehow most of us know that they both refer to something in relation to imparting information/instruction. To clear out the differences between the two we will first study the individual terms and then bring out the differences between the two.
Teaching is the communication of ideas, skills or information from the teacher or source of information to the student or any receiver. The information that is taught can be of any type. For example, a student taking a chemistry class may be taught about chemicals and how they react on combining with each other. This is the information that is taught to the student. The information again that is included in the process of teaching can vary. It can be either all truth or some information can be subjected to falsehood. The students are supposed to critically examine the information and then obtain the knowledge. Therefore teaching is aimed to impart knowledge or skill. Teaching focuses on imparting information so that students learn the proper methodologies and then apply the methodologies to make their own opinions in many things. Students may also question the information and the teacher in that case needs to satisfy the query by supporting it with proper evidence. In some other cases, the student is free to make his own opinion after taking a lesson. For example, after teaching a moral lesson, a student may be asked: how he will react in a certain situation? In this case it is the perspective of student that how he has grasped the teachings and then later is capable of making a decision. Now this decision again differs from one student to the other. One can expect numerous answers of the same question from the students of the same class. This is also not wrong, something that has been taught is examined by students and that later helps them in deciding the answer. However, this liberty is not provided in teaching facts, but these facts are always supported by relevant evidence. Thus, the questions can easily be answered by the teacher.
Indoctrination means teaching or inculcating a doctrine, principal, or ideology especially one with a particular point of view, as in the example of religious indoctrination. In religious indoctrination a student is taught religious beliefs. The key word in defining a indoctrination is belief- a belief can be described as an acceptance that the statement holds true, it is just the acceptance or opinion ( not supported by evidence as in case of beliefs).This means that it varies from other teachings in one broad sense; the teachings of indoctrination should not be critically examined. Indoctrination aims at teaching rigid beliefs, and these beliefs may not have any evidence to be true. It is generally used in context to religious beliefs where people tend to teach religious beliefs and the important thing is that, the person obtaining these beliefs cannot argue it and has to accept it the way it is. These beliefs are taught in such a manner that the student is unable to judge or evaluate these beliefs. It is generally used to teach political ideologies or religious ideologies.
The main differences between the teaching and indoctrination are: teaching is open to questions, students can always ask questions regarding the subject they are taught whereas indoctrination is like giving instructions, one needs to listen it and is supposed to follow it. In indoctrination, the student cannot question the subject matter. Again teaching is not biased whereas the indoctrination can have a biased approach. Teaching aims at developing brains of students, it provides them with the opportunity to argue things and evaluate things and then form an opinion whereas indoctrination has set opinion about the belief that is being taught and hence, the student’s opinion does not matter or taught in a manner that a student is not supposed to make his own opinion. Teaching is a positive activity in which students receive knowledge whereas indoctrination is mostly associated as a negative kind of teaching where students are expected to follow what is taught to them without making any enquiry. Thus sometimes indoctrination is also referred as brainwashing.
Image Courtesy: fossati.us, atheistrev.com
Add new comment